11/21/19

Societal Risks of Bariatric Surgery, Part II


Fat has become the evil we avoid at all costs. In our collective world of fantasy, one of only good fortune, endless riches, eternally youth, fat is the source of the evil we avoid. The dream is that remaining thin and perfecting our diet and exercise plan will allow us to revel in what was once unattainable: immortality.
Society has tacitly agreed that fat is culprit of all our woes. Accordingly, we must avoid eating fat (except fats deemed healthy) and we all just avoid fat people. As bias against race, gender and religion decreases on all fronts, bias against fat people is on the rise. They are seen as lazy, ignorant and lacking in all willpower. They represent everything distasteful in the world and must be avoided at all costs. They deserve what they have brought upon themselves.

The diet industry rests largely upon the theory of self-advocacy. With any specific diet, a person will successfully lose weight for good and transform their lives. The data proves that 98% of diets fail, so why would any new diet be more successful than the last? Since diets work by supposedly empowering people, those who fail are to blame. Certainly the diet can not be the failure.

The exercise industry is the same way. New exercise plans promise a life transformation including weight loss, new confidence and personal transformation. Lack of success is always a personal failure. The exercise program cannot be held accountable for false promises.

The medical establishment reinforces the concept of fat as the source of all illness. As doctors arrogantly explain the dubious relationship between weight and health, they offer no solutions mostly because there are no reasonable solutions to be found. Diets don’t work. Weight loss medications won’t work. Doctors easily shirk off any responsibility by blaming the patient.

Inevitably, the demoralized patient believes they are to blame for their weight and that their weight will shorten their lives considerably. The only path left is Bariatric surgery. Medicine pushes these patients towards surgery, and the centers have become large money makers for hospitals struggling to survive financially.

Perhaps Bariatric surgery is barbaric. It’s a last ditch effort to transform a person’s body and life by cutting away most of their stomach and decreasing their physical ability to eat food. The result is forced prolonged starvation: anatomical anorexia. The only way to lose weight is to create an eating disorder by any means.

If thinness is the only key to success in this world and the promises mentioned above, is it any wonder droves of people have signed up for surgery?

Watching people gradually find a way to eat again around the surgery, I have wondered what the long term results will show. I see so many patients eventually eat more regularly or overeat again after their bodies adjust to the surgery.

And how will we reassess the long term effects on so many people undergoing this procedure as they age? Surgery isn’t a permanent solution but only delays our inevitable need to face the judgment and bias around weight. It is a scary view of what the fantasy of thinness has wrought in our world.

11/14/19

Societal Risks of Bariatric Surgery, Part I


The medical establishment posits that Bariatric surgery is the newest and most effective way to combat issues with weight in our society. As previously explained in this blog, our bodies have adapted to the environment created by the food industry, namely processed foods meant to appeal to our most powerful tastes and that also wreak havoc on our metabolism. Rather than face the public health crisis caused by the food industry, surgery, which is now covered by insurance, is the solution of the moment.

The increase in average weight in the country is linked to worsening health. However, this link is questioned by many authorities. Movements like Health at Every Size present substantial evidence that proves otherwise. The power of the food industry has convinced society and doctors that people are to be blamed for their weight which causes poor health and that these people need help to fix their weight problem. There are medications meant to counteract this scourge which have limited benefit, but surgery is the increasingly common recommendation as a quick fix.

Bariatric surgery is essentially anatomical anorexia. Gastric sleeve surgery, the newest iteration, surgically separates 80-90% of one’s stomach leaving a very small, crescent shaped stomach. The result is the physical inability to manage no more than a few bites at every meal, at least for the first 6-12 months after surgery. The Bariatric surgical centers focus solely on weight loss. Their success is measured by the number of patients who lose a certain percentage of body weight over the first year or two. Long-term results, let alone overall health, are secondary.

But surgery essentially leads to drastic food restriction over a long period of time. By any other definition, this looks like anorexia. Any starvation, however it is imposed, can lead to very strong hunger that triggers overeating or binging. Also, restriction over a period of time leads to malnutrition no matter the weight of the person. The surgical programs don’t consider overall nutrition or the health consequences of such prolonged limited eating. Instead, they focus on improved blood sugar and blood pressure, metrics that increase insurance coverage. What benefit is there to swap one set of medical issues for another?

Based on how easy it is to sway medical opinion—the continued manipulation by the pharmaceutical industry is the clearest example, it’s not surprising that other more powerful forces have convinced medicine to take this approach to treat larger patients. But how is it that thousands of fat people blame themselves so much that they endure risky surgery time and again? Why is it that no one is questioning this barbaric practice? I’ll address this in the next post.

11/7/19

The Fallacy of Willpower in Eating Disorders


Clinicians regular conflate eating disorder recovery and willpower. For people with anorexia, they say that willpower is the essential ingredient to be able to follow a meal plan. For bulimia, therapists describe willpower as the main way to avoid binges. For binge eating disorder or compulsive overeating, willpower is the only way to stop eating.

All research into treatment shows that this therapeutic approach is ineffective, yet the theory is pervasive in the clinical community, to the detriment of all those seeking help.

The focus on willpower as a part of eating disorder recovery, despite its clear ineffectiveness, is due to three issues.

First, therapists struggle to manage the helplessness and powerlessness they often feel when treating people with eating disorders. Therapy may include insightful sessions, a clear understanding of the cause of the eating disorder and a definite plan moving forward. Even still, the person may make no or marginal progress. Without any clear culprit, the therapist can easily blame willpower—the patient—for the failure to move forward, absolve themselves of responsibility and avoid more frustration.

Second, the concept of willpower camouflages a therapist’s lack of knowledge or experience treating people with eating disorders. Willpower reflects an aspect of therapy called motivational interviewing first adapted for people with substance abuse issues. Although there is some benefit utilizing this treatment approach for eating disorders, the therapy does not take into account the greatest difference between the two: food. However, it’s a convenient way to explain why someone is not progressing in treatment and instead blame the patient for her illness. It behooves patient and therapist to get a second opinion or try a different course when a clinician is unclear how to proceed rather than attribute a stall in progress to a largely irrelevant treatment modality.

Third, the therapist is unwittingly reinforcing the eating disorder mindset when focusing on willpower. Since this approach is wholly ineffective, it only makes the patients feel more inadequate and more helpless. Rather than trying to find a new way the circumvent the illness, the therapist expresses frustration in the most facile way: leading the patient back to the helpless state of the illness.

When a patient encounters a team focusing on willpower as a core part of treatment, the patient ought to both confront the team about this approach and, more importantly, seek new help. Using willpower as a fulcrum to leverage recovery inevitably fails and only reinforces the illness. Better treatment exists elsewhere.

10/31/19

Eating Disorders vs. the Collective Focus on Weight and Food

The cultural views of weight and being fat factor heavily in the clinical approach to treating people with eating disorders. Those with anorexia are often lauded for their weight even when the illness severely limits their lives. Fat people are shamed so much they develop body distortions or eating disorders through endless dieting and even Bariatric surgery. Bulimia is sometimes seen as a necessary evil to manage weight. 
The lens through which many people understand eating disorders is itself distorted by the vilification of fat and glorification of thinness. 

In order to make more sense of eating disorders, the distinction between what these illnesses are and the societal distortions about body size and shape is critical. 

Eating disorders are characterized by abnormal eating behaviors: chronic starvation, binging, purging, excessive exercise, laxative abuse. However, the true nature of an eating disorder is psychological. Obsessive thoughts about weight, food and self-loathing dominate the minds of people with eating disorders. These thoughts make it almost impossible to live a full life. Even those who objectively seem to be living talk in secret of how much mental energy they use for the eating disorder. Their lives are not theirs to live. 

Society’s views about weight reinforce much of these eating disorder thoughts. The endless praise for thinness, pervasiveness of dieting and marketing for diets and exercise all confirm that the underlying basis for the eating disorder appears to be valid. It seems as if everyone is focused on weight and food. 

When people hear about or discuss eating disorders, the difference between our collective focus on food and weight doesn’t seem much different from an eating disorder on the surface. 

People without eating disorders may engage in these thoughts and behaviors, but their lives go on. They can let go of these thoughts, stop a diet or exercising and think nothing of it. Someone with an eating disorder cannot make these changes without the illness consuming their lives. 

Changing the obsession with food and weight is not a short-term solution because the obsession is too ingrained in our national ethos. It’s critical to recognize that eating disorders are true illnesses, many levels more severe and all-consuming than simply altering one’s daily diet. Comparing eating disorders and the general focus on food and weight completely misunderstands how severe and destructive eating disorders really are.

10/24/19

Present and Future of Eating Disorder Treatment


Eating disorders have complex and multifactorial causes. With our still limited knowledge of brain function, genetics, environment, behaviors and brain pathways all are part of what leads to an eating disorder. Dieting and food restriction may be the number one risk factor, but the still basic understanding of our brains leaves medicine with only a cursory sense of why and how a diet causes anorexia in one person, bulimia in another and only a few days of hunger in a third.
Since there is no standard approach to treating any eating disorder, clinicians or researchers tend to recommend treatment based on their own personal bent rather than overall knowledge about these illnesses. Some treatment is primarily pharmacological, some psychoanalytic and others behavioral or relational. The fact that clinicians have so many approaches reflects the difficulty finding adequate and successful treatment.

Some approaches seem to have benefit: high doses of Prozac for severe Bulimia or binge eating, cognitive behavioral therapy for bulimia, family based therapy for some adolescents with anorexia. However, there are no treatments known to work broadly based on repeated research studies.

These facts can be demoralizing for patients, especially those who don’t get better quickly after the first series of treatment. As they emerge from the initial shock and preliminary steps into treatment, families and patients can get bogged down in the difficulty finding the best treatment pathway, assessing the hodgepodge of residential treatment programs and combing through the informal training process for clinicians who treat eating disorders.

There is some research on the horizon that is promising. One direction is starting to delineate the hormones that modulate hunger, fullness and the gastrointestinal system. It is interesting and useful but not yet enough to lead to effective medications on the market. Perhaps these medications can open doors to at least moderating the strength of some eating disorder symptoms and improving outcomes.

In addition research into the experience of appetite and fullness in the brain is also present in academic circles, yet these neural pathways are complex and just starting to be understood.

For now, the most effective treatment aims to circumvent and weaken behavioral pathways for all eating disorders. By figuring out how to help people identify the repetitive eating disorder thoughts and behaviors and change them accordingly may be an involved and long process, but it’s one that works long-term and is effective. This therapy does the work medications may help do more quickly in the future.

The truth is that effective treatment is out there for everyone. It may be hard to find or take a long time, but it is important to keep trying and know that recovery is possible.

10/17/19

Why is it so Hard to Find Competent Treatment for Eating Disorders


It is notoriously difficult for people with eating disorders or for their families to find competent help in the mental health field. Despite the increasing incidence of eating disorders, the most frequent complaint I hear is how difficult it is to navigate the eating disorder treatment world.
People frequently say they have seen treatment providers who purport they know how to treat eating disorders and then turn out to have minimal experience. Over and over again, they report the ignorant things professionals have said about eating disorders. This frustration often leads to giving up and a sense that there is no real help to be found.

Even when I cannot see someone, I will try to provide connections to the eating disorder treatment world in New York. Similarly, people contact me from all over the country, and even in other countries, with the same complaint seeking any kind of guidance.

It’s confusing how a set of disorders so prevalent have such limited infrastructure in the mental health community.

There are a number of reasons for this discrepancy. First, the training programs to teach clinicians how to treat people with eating disorders are very limited and completely unregulated. The programs vary from analytic programs, short-term certificates and informal training at residential programs. All these training areas focus on their own way of treating eating disorders but don’t coordinate to teach an overview of treatment and basic knowledge about these illnesses.

Accordingly, there is no formal accreditation for clinicians to attain and advertise. Instead, any experience helping with eating disorders will do, and clinicians can say they have experience treating people with eating disorders even if that’s not true.

Similarly, most academic medical centers have limited treatment and knowledge of eating disorders as well. Instead, the mainstay of treatment is residential centers which are for profit private companies and have no motive to consider treatment and wellness as their ultimate goal. Although these programs can be beneficial, they don’t help codify a basic knowledge for clinicians in the community and don’t encourage research into best practices.

Three more social components of eating disorders make them very different from other illnesses in psychiatry. First, eating disorders are relatively new and there is a short track record for understanding and treating them. Second, treatment is difficult and frequently long-lasting, something anathema to the current mental health world. Third, these illnesses have a central medical component typically not part of psychiatric treatment. These three differences appear to have made it less desirable for the medical community to prioritize treatment for these illnesses.

The lack of formal training for and complex social aspects of eating disorders have created a void in competent eating disorder treatment. The real question is how to recognize this public health crisis (outlined in the last post) and begin to change the treatment landscape to make good treatment easier to find.

10/10/19

The Number One Risk Factor for an Eating Disorder: Dieting


The precipitating factor for every eating disorder is a diet. It’s not a coincidence that the number of eating disorders in this country skyrocketed when dieting became a nationwide fad in the late 1960’s and early 1970’s. As dieting continues to be regular practice for people in so many communities, eating disorders have become a larger public health problem.
Dieting over an extended period of time triggers a powerful genetic mechanism in all of us to survive famine. The human species has persevered in part because of our biological ability to adapt to limited availability of food for extended periods and utilize times of abundance wisely. 

Dieting mimics famine for our biological constitution. Thus, what we now describe as a disorder actually reflects a built-in adaptation to the lack of food. For some, prolonged dieting will trigger anorexia: the ability to survive on extremely small amounts of food and simultaneously shift all conscious awareness towards searching for and hoarding food. For others, dieting triggers a version of binging, hoarding food by eating long past the feeling of fullness and storing extra energy in our bodies. And many people diet for a few days or a week and just give up. 

The main difference between eating disorders and famine is that these adaptive measures are triggered by conscious decisions to diet rather than external environmental factors. Nonetheless, the behavioral and psychological symptoms are the activation of programmed survival mechanisms currently triggered by maladaptive means.

The lack of this basic knowledge about eating disorders frequently leads family members, friends and clinicians to blame people for their eating disorders. Rather than understand the medical explanation of an eating disorder, people become frustrated with such irrational, nonsensical behavior and simply implore the person to eat a hamburger or drink a milkshake.

Instead, recovery needs to involve an extended period of normal eating that will reassure one’s body and mind that regular nutrition is on the way: the famine is over. Once that period of eating lasts long enough, the psychological component of the eating disorder will diminish over time, with consistent psychological and emotional support.

However, it’s critical people don’t forget the only clear risk factor for developing an eating disorder: dieting.