9/6/13

Discharge Planning


Treatment programs have a valuable but very specific role in recovery from an eating disorder. The focused and intense time spent on getting better empowers people to realize that full recovery is a viable endpoint. People learn an enormous amount about their illness. The immediate gains are obvious and, in a positive environment, even points of pride.

In addition, spending time with a group of people all zeroing in on treatment is a relief after months or years of isolation from being sick. Above all, a sustained period of being nourished diminishes the physical, emotional and psychological symptoms of an eating disorder drastically. More often than not, people complete a program in a better place than when they started. Although that may seem like an obvious statement, intuition is often not helpful when it comes to choosing treatment for people with eating disorders so this is a crucial fact to remember.

Still, entering a program isn't the best choice for everyone despite the likely short-term improvement. Research and experience prove that these gains don't last more than a few months for most people for several reasons.

Eating disorder treatment is time-consuming and expensive. Much thought needs to go into the decision both in terms of potential benefit and the likelihood of treatment kick-starting true, long lasting recovery. No one has enough resources to make repeated hospitalization a viable option: it only reinforces that an eating disorder is a chronic, incurable illness.

A quick relapse can be incredibly demoralizing and delay recovery for months and years. Too many people who go to treatment programs prematurely just cycle through the different options for treatment without any true progress. Granted, medical emergencies such as being severely malnourished or low potassium from purging may necessitate urgent inpatient treatment; however, it behooves clinicians and patients to consider likely outcomes before committing blindly to a detrimental course of treatment.

Any reasoned approach to residential treatment must include discharge planning at the very start of the treatment. Too many programs are so intently focused on the day-to-day operation of their bubble that they neglect to fully consider how challenging the transition is from 24 hour support to just a few hours per day at most. Even the best programs struggle to include the outpatient team in treatment decisions and discharge planning, even though it's the outpatient team that will implement the treatment and that knows how reasonable and realistic the plan is. Outpatient clinicians feel they can take a break when a patient goes into residential treatment, but that only worsens long-term outcome.

Discharge planning needs to start on the day of admission to residential treatment. Doing so will force inpatient and outpatient teams to communicate right away. That interaction will uncover basic assumptions of both teams and allow for debate and thorough consideration of all possibilities.

Moreover, it will give time to present the options to the patient so she can have a say in the process as well. A patient involved in these decisions will have ownership of the treatment and will be much more like to follow through. 

Since the benefit of these steps is pretty obvious, the real question is why doesn't this happen automatically? I don't have a good answer. Part of it may be the disjointed nature of care for people with eating disorders. There are no guidelines for transitions in and out of residential programs. Also there tends to be a sense of superiority in American clinical care which enables competition between various stages of eating disorder treatment, not collaboration. Finally, the lack of any centralized health care agency means there is no accountability for clinicians in their decision making, a necessity to keep clinicians honest and humble.

The bottom line is that discharge planning and continuity of care needs to be of primary importance. It's the key component for treatment programs to be steps in recovery, rather than brief blips of wellness.

8/23/13

Debunking The Myth that People with Eating Disorders can't get Better


There's a myth about eating disorders that people can't really fully recover. I have encountered many clinicians in the community who may not state this directly but organize treatment as if these were incurable, chronic illnesses. Even people who know little about eating disorders often ask me if any of my patients get better, fully expecting the answer to be no. This commonly held myth is widely believed and leads many people seeking treatment to give up hope. 

To be honest, I've thought a lot about why eating disorders are viewed this way. The body of medical and psychological literature reports that people can get well. There are many books of recovered people describing their painful, but ultimately successful, path to full recovery. There are many clinicians who have fully recovered themselves. So if all the easily found information doesn't propagate a message of hopelessness, where does this myth come from?

I think the first culprit is the belief that having an eating disorder is a lifestyle choice, not a devastating illness. Although media outlets don't state this directly, there are very regular headlines that infer that restricting food intake and increasing exercise to maintain very thin weights are the ideal lifestyle choices one can make, not the signs of an illness. 

Accordingly, it can be difficult for many people to differentiate between these supposedly "healthy" goals and an eating disorder. In fact, many magazine articles imply that choosing to eat less and overexercise is simultaneously healthy and synonymous with eating disorders, an extremely confusing and contradictory message.

The truth is that people with eating disorders struggle to eat every meal, not because of vanity, but because it's a symptom of an illness. To most people, it's almost unthinkable to have trouble eating, so it only makes sense to view eating disorders as a lifestyle choice. When people cannot comprehend something, they will concoct a theory that makes sense to them, so explaining to people that not being able to eat is a symptom, rather than a choice, is very challenging.

The second likely cause for the myth has to do with how long people stay sick. Many patients are sick for a long time before seeking help and, once they take the first step, experience treatment with a clinician who isn't knowledgeable about eating disorders. These initial forays into therapy imprint the idea that treatment won't ever really make a difference. It also means that many patients are sick for years before starting a true path to recovery. That extended time without much change in the illness makes it appear to others that eating disorders are lifelong. For friends and family, it's not surprising that they start to believe this will be a chronic curse, an inescapable maze the person is trapped in for life.

I have written much in this blog about family support. Bridging years of separation caused by the eating disorder is challenging but critical to recovery. I find that a significant part of recovery rests on being able to educate families and patients that eating disorders are curable. This step can invigorate all involved to muster enough energy and attention through the difficult process of getting better.

The raw, painful, emotional experience of nourishing oneself and re-entering life doesn't look like getting better, at first. The person usually seems to have things more together when she was even sicker because the eating disorder symptoms numb any emotions. Starting to eat again instead unleashes these feelings. If family and friends work hard to understand that the painful process is necessary to lead to full recovery, the chance of really getting better goes up significantly.

There's one other reason our society has trouble seeing people with eating disorders get well. It has to do with how we glorify these illnesses. Idealizing thinness, even being clearly underweight, reflects our collective understanding about eating disorders. The process of getting sick with an eating disorder is encouraged by the outside world. There are too many stories of adolescent girls enjoying praise as they lose weight only to find that they cannot stop the descent into an eating disorder.

As long as we make extreme thinness a goal, we will conflate desire with disease. In this case, how can anyone see an eating disorder as curable? Part of shattering the myth that eating disorders are lifelong is convincing people that there is nothing desirable about being too thin or about being sick. No one would choose a lifestyle that strips so much of life away.

8/7/13

Family Support in Eating Disorder Recovery


For those lucky enough to have it, family support is a critical part of eating disorder recovery. Family dynamics though often play a role in the inception of an eating disorder so that type of support is far from a given. In fact, distancing oneself from family often behooves a person trying to get well. That doesn't mean families cause eating disorders, a once standard explanation for the cause of these illnesses. However, if the family situation wreaks emotional and psychological havoc, the child can be more susceptible to developing an eating disorder to begin with and can have more success in recovery with separation from family dynamics.

In the situations where families can heal from prior emotional troubles and provide support for the child in recovery, family education is of primary importance. As I have written extensively in this blog, it's not intuitive for anyone to understand the fundamental struggles of someone with an eating disorder.

Eating meals when hungry and stopping when full are standard daily activities for everyone, much like brushing your teeth. Imagining each bite of food to be a monumental struggle is beyond most people's comprehension.

Families need to read books, talk to clinicians and, most importantly, speak to their loved one regularly. This immersion in self-education is a necessary and meaningful attempt to truly understand the torture of an eating disorder and will enable family members to learn how to comfort and support their family member who is ill.

Typically, the person with an eating disorder has withdrawn during the illness. The symptoms, both behaviors and thoughts, are all consuming and lead to isolation from daily life and interpersonal interactions. So families become used to that distance and imagine the family member functioning independently, self-sufficiently and much more capably than she really can.

The process of recovery and re-engaging with the family can be a shock. This typically independent family member instead appears very unstable, intensely emotional and very scared about the seemingly innocuous task of eating several times per day. As recovery progresses, even more so when the progress is steady, she becomes much more emotionally unstable rather than less in the following months and much more outspoken about needing help.

Anyone's instinctive conclusion would be that these emotions represent regression, not steps towards recovery, but the opposite is actually true. Nourishing one's body and mind unleashes intense emotions and forces the ill family member to create new ways of coping with daily life without the numbing effects of the eating disorder symptoms. Not only does this surprise families but also elicits powerful emotional reactions. 

The most common family reaction is frustration. As recovery continues and eating remains difficult, family members lose patience to remain outwardly supportive. It becomes more and more difficult to understand why a meal could be so hard even after a period of treatment. Families inevitably express the same reaction at several points of recovery: "Just eat more food!" "It can't be so hard to have breakfast!" "Why do you still feel so bad after all this time?" 

These comments are part of their family member's eating disorder internal dialogue every day. In fact, these are the thoughts she is trying to escape. She is aware of how hard it is to get better. She knows she can't do something that is simple and automatic to people without eating disorders. She routinely has similar critical thoughts that remind her of these facts many times per day. When families confirm these thoughts with their own frustrations, the family member will quickly retreat back into her shell. Those reactions only reinforce the illness.

As challenging as it can be for families, the best support is always kindness and compassion. Anyone with an eating disorder has to deal with constant internal criticism. That pressure is exhausting and demoralizing. No amount of kindness and encouragement is too much.

Kind comments, even repeated every day through the process of recovery, make a world of difference: "I'm so proud of you." "How are you doing today?" "We all are behind you and know how hard you're working every day." "We love you and will always support you any way we can to help you get well." 

If family struggles can be put in the past, then consistent, reliable, compassionate support will help the family member persist through the struggle to recover. If family dynamics have been too painful or traumatic, then the clinician must make it safe for the person to protect herself from family in order to get well. The most important quality of any support is kindness. It is what makes recovery possible.

7/25/13

The Role of Coping Skills in Eating Disorder Treatment


Eating disorder treatment programs focus a significant portion of education in recovery on coping skills. These tools don't always translate easily from a closely monitored program into the real world. As a psychiatrist and therapist who works with many patients just discharged from a program, I help people negotiate the transition back into their lives and have worked hard to make sense of how coping skills can be constructive in recovery. I think the idea is useful but could also benefit from some clarification.

The concept of coping skills has a research foundation and therefore a pertinent beginning. The cognitive behavioral therapy model--the most used modality to treat eating disorders--helps patients identify moments in a day when they become vulnerable to eating disorder symptoms, mostly binging or restricting. Once the pattern and triggers are clear to the patient, the next question is obvious: what do I do next to stop the behaviors? Therapists don't always have the answers. It's easier to identify the patterns than it is to break them.

The default answer is to use coping skills. Effectively, this means sit with the urges to do eating disorder behaviors and distract yourself with a variety of mundane activities until the urge passes. It's assumed the urge will pass. This assumption is a result of the original research used to support CBT, first performed in mice, supported by increasing knowledge about brain function then applied to humans. The research conclusion is scientifically robust yet simple: one's urge to do something (drink alcohol, perform a compulsion as in OCD, avoid a scary place, use ED symptoms) will diminish if one can push through the anxiety and urges over a period of time, generally weeks. The gradual decrease in anxiety is called habituation.

With handy research in mind, the next goal of treatment is delaying the symptoms in any manner possible. Coping skills tend to be typical daily activities that pass the time: walking, reading, seeing a movie, calling a friend, painting your nails. Without other alternatives, most patients will try the coping skills with varying success depending on their progress in recovery. It's rare that someone doesn't throw up their hands and say, "There's got to be something better than this in treatment." But that's not necessarily the case. 

Treatment programs have, for obvious reasons, much more success stopping the eating disorder behaviors than outpatient options. It's much harder to follow through with the symptoms when you're being watched 24/7. So people in treatment programs have hours during the day when they have to sit with the urges and can't do anything about it. This provides ample time to practice coping skills. But these opportunities are just practice. It's only the real thing when doing the eating disorder symptoms is a viable option. That transition from the constant observation of a program to freedom in the real world makes applying coping skills tricky. 

I very much respect and use the concept in treatment. When eating disorder behaviors are routine, changing them, as with changing any ingrained behavior pattern, takes one's full attention and requires a long period of discomfort. Habituation seems to occur faster in some situations than in others, and eating may be too innate and ingrained a behavior to change quickly. In truth, using coping skills is a kinder term for white-knuckling it. But any recovery from an eating disorder requires it.

What the use of coping skills points out to me is the weakest link in the recovery. When someone is able to identify risky periods during the day, the points of vulnerability--the times when the eating disorder threatens to take over--become apparent. It's critical to realize that failing at coping skills is not failing at recovery. It just points out where work needs to happen in treatment.

There is a certain kind of learning through repetition, namely slips into eating disorder symptoms, that happens back in the real world outside of a residential treatment program. Those times when coping skills don't work typically point out where someone doesn't yet believe or understand the psychological adjustments necessary to push through the urges. Examples are not being able to eat enough to satisfy hunger or the inability tolerate being full or the fear of gaining weight or not being "small" anymore. If a significant amount of time in therapy is devoted to arguing or bargaining around these issues, then it's clear what the snag is. Meal plans and adequate nutrition aren't bargaining chips or variables. They're the only way clinicians can track medical stability and progress in recovery and the only path towards recovery. Although there are different, often creative, ways to reach these goals, in the end they must be met. 

Coping skills work best once a patient and therapist are on the same page with these central aspects of recovery. Then there's a purpose to experiencing long periods of discomfort or even pain. Once the eating disorder thought process is no longer primary in someone's self-assessment, white knuckling it becomes a difficult but necessary part of getting well.

7/11/13

A New Take on Identity and Eating Disorder Recovery


Far From the Tree, a true masterpiece of a book written by Andrew Solomon, addresses the link between identity and various illnesses and disabilities for children and their parents. I can't do justice to the work, but his thesis has clear implications for people with eating disorders and is very relevant to this blog.

In fact, he briefly addresses anorexia and bulimia, referencing pro-Ana and pro-Mia websites as examples of activist movements for people with illness or disability. However, he quickly dismisses the premise because eating disorders are fatal and thus cannot compare to similar movements such as for deaf people or dwarfs. 

To be fair, Mr. Solomon didn't research eating disorders in the way he so thoroughly did the other issues chronicled in his book. He may have been better off leaving this one alone, but he does touch upon something critical and confusing about how eating disorders are linked to identity.

The controversial eating disorder websites are certainly dangerous, and supporting an eating disorder as identity only increases the morbidity and mortality of these diseases. But in light of the topic of identity, the pro-ED sites also reinforce two things necessary for successful recovery. First, much as the other illnesses Mr. Solomon discusses, people with eating disorders did not choose their disease and don't choose to stay sick any more than someone with Down's Syndrome or cerebral palsy. Second, unlike these other issues, people with eating disorders can get better but the process involves relinquishing the core of identity since adolescence--the opposite of the premise of the book.

Mr. Solomon draws the reader in to story after story of heartbreak, resilience, transformation and acceptance. After hundreds of pages, it's exhausting but exhilarating to realize these stories could go on ad infinitum. A crucial part of each person's path is acceptance of the limitations of the illness combined with taking pleasure in what life can still offer. Implied in acceptance is coming to terms with the identity of the disability or illness, both for the person afflicted and for the parents.

There is a clear demarcation here between eating disorders and the illnesses described in this book. Chronic eating disorders always intertwine the thoughts and behaviors of illness into identity, inextricably and with finality. The result is that the person feels bereft even at the thought of letting their illness go.

Recovery involves stripping away all sense of oneself so that this person can start over, raw, unprotected and very much alone but with the hope of a life free of this terrible affliction. Disavowing one's identity for anyone discussed in Far From the Tree is denial and leads to an extremely limiting life. Doing so with an eating disorder is a painful but necessary step in recovery.

The activism in the eating disorder world must explain that recovery involves relinquishing identity to start over. Learning how to live without one's guiding force, destructive though it was, is a tall order. Recovery means creating a new self and life, not just eating more food.

6/19/13

The Process of Recovery from an Eating Disorder


Recovery from an eating disorder is a process. For people who see the world in very black-and-white terms, namely those with eating disorders, the concept of process is a tall order. It implies ups and downs, swings that feel very powerful emotionally and days when all seems for nought. Years of an eating disorder wear down even the preternaturally hopeful and binds any optimism into a vortex of doom. In such a dramatic place the whole idea of process appears incredibly naive.

But the process of recovery is what we clinicians have to offer. Put simply, simple tools practiced over time really do work. Write a food journal every day; plan your meals the night before; be active during the day, especially after meals; be around people, even when you want to be alone; and pay attention to your feelings for they are the best clues to stay on the path to recovery.

When the person in recovery knows that her therapist and treatment team are willing to go through that process too, she knows she's not alone. That makes all the difference in the world. 

The concept of process implies another necessary component in recovery: resilience. The path of an eating disorder typically leaves people feeling completely powerless. The best laid plans falter from the get go. A day derailed early never gets back on track. The mantra of the person with an eating disorder is "I'll start towards recovery tomorrow," but tomorrow never comes. It's a new idea to contemplate resilience in the face of the eating disorder commands. That simple suggestions and support can alter the eating disorder symptoms feels miraculous. It feels impossible for a day to start off challenging and turn out all right. Yet experiencing resilience revitalizes true belief in hope again. 

Once process and resilience become real to the person in recovery, she begins to experience something very new and raw. The despair connected with the lost time of an eating disorder and the numbing effect of the symptoms both limit any knowledge of the true emotional experience of daily life.

Regular people learn to cope with their own emotions through years of practice. They come to know themselves and how they can live with their feelings, some constructively and some less so. A person in recovery is suddenly thrust into a world of raw, intense emotions, ones she hasn't experienced in a long time. Even a crash course in personal exploration doesn't prepare her for the jarring blast of the panoply of emotions: sadness, anger, disappointment, shame, frustration and fear. The pull to use eating disorder symptoms and return to numbness is very strong, a salve for all the open wounds, but one that only leads back to despair.

When it comes to the emotional life of recovery, each person needs to understand the process too. Time will heal those wounds. Emotions may feel like a bottomless pit, but the bottom comes before you know it. Emotions for someone in recovery are, in the end, the same as everyone else's. It just takes time to get used to them. The simple things people do in order to weather emotions works for those in recovery: talk to someone, journal, watch a movie or just cry. These tools seem inadequate, perhaps even trivializing, at first, but emotions are just a part of life, a reality of being human. No powerful intellect or personal mastery allows anyone a pass on feelings. The mastery is akin to acceptance: the process of succumbing to emotions in the moment, even of you're unsure of the path ahead, is bearable when you remember you'll be all right in the end. 

This last step points out one more step in the process, trust. A person in recovery doesn't know how to trust their own instincts or ability to make reasonable decisions each day, let alone trust anyone else to guide them. The eating disorder has been the only guide in life. Yet believing in hope, resilience and emotions requires trust in oneself, clinicians and family. This is not a path one can forge alone.

The ups and downs, moments of elation or panic and feelings of hopelessness and despair will be unbearable for a person completely alone. People to share these experiences with and shoulders to cry on will mitigate what feels insurmountable. That support enables the person with an eating disorder to work just as hard the next day until recovery starts to feel like it's paying off. Given the necessary time, the process of recovery works. People sick with eating disorders do get well. 

6/6/13

"Fat Talk:" the Startling Column in The New York Times


It was surprising to see a health column in the New York Times about the risks of women engaging in "fat talk." For years this weekly section has been a soapbox for over-exercising and supposed healthy eating, and, in the journalist Jane Brody’s column, the weekly standard of the section, at times leaning even towards unethical. The increasing attention to topics such as treatment of chronic running injuries in middle age has been worrisome. But perhaps the growing media shift away from body and weight finally caught the paper’s eye. 

The article raises awareness and provides evidence for the risks of women who bond over body and weight concerns. The desire for connectedness among women, unsurprisingly in today's world, often includes discussion of weight and body obsession, the current defining piece of a woman's identity. This "fat talk," as the article points out, only worsens a woman's self-image and confidence by validating weight and body as central to a woman's self-worth. The take-away message is clear: fat talk has to go.

The news in the article isn't the headline but the paper it appears in. It's truly notable that a newspaper that touts a journalist like Jane Brody would make this shift on women and body image. The article also presents a true problem for women today: how can "fat talk" become taboo?

As a clinician treating people with eating disorders, I believe a larger transformation in women’s thinking would ease treatment greatly. And if a journalist like Jane Brody could be convinced that food and body, under the guise of better health, aren't the only virtues to aspire to, there is hope for the community at large.

One recurrent disagreement for people in recovery is whether women's behavior and beliefs about food and weight just normalizes eating disordered thinking. Many women with eating disorders feel like everyone is concerned with weight so why are they so different. Clinicians try to point out how personally destructive eating disorders are but can be thwarted by the media attention to food and weight. Until now, columns like Jane Brody's certainly don't make it any easier. If a woman so distorted in her thinking about food and weight can write for the Times, then patients feel justified to hang onto many eating disorder beliefs as normal, healthy thoughts.

True recovery from an eating disorder or freedom from the tyranny of disordered, obsessive eating needs a real transformation in thought process. Just altering eating habits and exercise without ending the waste of mental and emotional energy on the pursuit of a diet or body shape is ineffective and pointless. But it's a hard sell to women to reevaluate their self-image and satisfaction and consider other criteria. It's one thing to help someone recover and another to ask them to be a pioneer in a new world where women are free from the constant scrutiny of shape and weight.

Perhaps this is only the first step in this column’s transformation. It's significant for the paper to recognize and write about the dangers of fat talk. One hopes the editorial staff realizes that years of articles displaying public obsession with running and food could bolster many women's distorted thinking and behavior. One article that implies there must be an alternate way women can connect is important but only the beginning of a more complete message I hope the paper can embrace.

That's the step this column has yet to take. For a woman like Jane Brody, whose identity centers on eating disordered activities and as the major health writer at the Times, she faces a monumental task to reassess her sense of herself and acknowledge the time lost to a fruitless goal. Some attention to food choice and regular exercise clearly has benefits, but the limited evidence points to the obvious: don't subsist on fast food and don't sit on the couch all day. The rest, a large part of her years of work, is myth and hearsay.

A much braver step for such a respected science and health newspaper section would be to question the value of spending so much time and energy on dietary choice and exercise. For a paper with such a platform, the story of a personal transformation could model a change in philosophy unknown in any public domain. The behavior of this longstanding journalist has outwitted the Times' editorial staff for many years. However, the process of a public, personal awakening to her own struggle with fat talk and fat thoughts, even behind the facade of a science writer, would have a significant impact in these changing times.