The symptoms of eating disorders shift with cultural norms and trends more than any other psychiatric disorder. Moreover, the tenets of what makes an eating disorder powerful are widely accepted as long as they are moderated to match those norms.
Eating less, losing weight, exercising and compensating for “indulging” are part of daily life and considered “healthy choices.” Only when extreme does the normal focus on body and weight shift from adult responsibility to illness.
The pressures to be thin and lose weight are the primary risk factors for eating disorders, as I have written extensively in this blog. The desire for thinness at all cost drives people to restrict their food and triggers any underlying predisposition to an eating disorder.
Thus, eating disorders are a result of our social climate driven by communal needs and representative of public measures for success and achievement. Borne out of the norms that became widely seen in the media of the late 1960’s and early 1970’s, the idealization of a thin—often exceedingly thin—body created an entirely new class of mental illness.
In the world of psychiatry, that is unheard of.
Some mental illnesses now debunked reflected social trends, such as the profoundly prejudiced claims of homosexuality as an illness, but in this case, the changing trends triggered latent a biological adaptation to starvation and turned it into widespread illness.
The movements to accept all size bodies, such as body positivity or Health at Every Size, have their moment but inevitably fade when the newest fad to lose weight emerges.
Eating disorder recovery nevertheless has to attempt to counter the collective message about body and encourage people to eat more, gain weight and still find ways to accept and love themselves—a tall order for typically young people seeking self-worth and external validation in our society. But the eating disorder treatment field doesn’t have much else to offer.
Granted, there is more to life than a fleeting sense of accomplishment about fitting into a certain size jeans or weighing a specific number. That underlying message, when reinforced often enough, begins to ring true. The years of suffering and loss to the illness won’t be returned, and the personal suffering endured by the afflicted person and their family and friends creates scars that often don’t heal.
It’s never easy for patients to have perspective when immersed in the illness. Even so, I find that education about the nature of eating disorders and the scope of recent history sometimes plant a seed for recovery that grows faster than expected.
This is an avoidable history and one that shows our willingness to sacrifice the health and exuberance of youth, especially girls and young women, for a shared delusion that being thin matters more than anything. This delusion couldn’t be further from the truth.